The Social Media Advertising Trap

If your entire advertising budget is going to social media, we need to talk.

I get it. It’s familiar. It’s easy. You can throw money at Facebook or Instagram and feel like you’re doing something. But if you’ve ever actually set up a Meta ad campaign, you’ve probably noticed something… the targeting? Painfully generic.

It wasn’t always this bad. Back in the pre-2020 days, advertisers could drill down on hyper-specific audiences. But after privacy updates and the rollback of tracking capabilities, social media ad targeting isn’t what it used to be.

For some businesses—like restaurants using retargeting pixels—social can still be a valuable tool. But if you need to reach specific, high-value audiences with precision, social media is not where you should be spending your money.

Where Should You Be Advertising? Look Around.

Ever notice ads when you open Hulu? Or when you're listening to a podcast? When you check the weather or find a recipe? What about those ads that seem to follow you around the internet like they’re reading your mind?

You can do that.

Not just Fortune 500 brands, not just big corporations—you.

And here’s the thing: this type of advertising is way more effective than social media.

Let’s Talk About Targeting

The average person spends only 30 minutes of their day on Facebook. They spend the rest of their time scrolling random websites, streaming TV, listening to podcasts, and using apps. That’s where you should be advertising.

And the targeting? Miles and miles ahead of what social media can offer.

Unlike Facebook, which has been stripped of its best targeting features, premium ad networks have access to:

Browsing history (what people are actually searching for)

Credit card data (what they’re actually spending money on)

Location tracking (where they’re actually going)

Yes, it sounds a little creepy. But when done right, it’s just good marketing.

Why You Can’t Run These Ads Yourself (And Why That’s a Good Thing)

Here’s where things get interesting. Unlike Facebook, where anyone with a credit card can launch a campaign, premium ad platforms like The Trade Desk don’t just let anyone in.

To access the best audience data, you need to spend $1 million a year. That’s why most businesses go through an agency or media buyer—because we already have that access.

And trust me, it’s worth it.

“But What About Google Ads? Can’t I Just Run Display Ads Through Google?”

Technically, yes, you can. But here’s why that’s not the best move:

Google Ads Look Easy—But They’re Not. Google makes it seem like you can just set up an ad and let it run. But if you don’t understand bidding, auctions, and keyword strategy, you’ll burn through your budget fast.

I learned this the hard way. I passed the Google Ads certification, ran campaigns myself, and guess what? We got website traffic. But no leads.

Why? Because the traffic was junk. High bids, wrong audience, short time frame, wasted budget.

Google Is Full of Bot Traffic. Google’s display network is notorious for spam traffic—fake clicks, low-quality sites, and inflated conversion numbers. Ever noticed how your Facebook and Google ads tend to bring in random, irrelevant leads? That’s because not all traffic is good traffic.

Search ads (SEM) can work well—but only if you’re already creating demand elsewhere. Google Display ads? Cheap for a reason.

The Trade Desk, on the other hand, only runs ads on the top 5,000 websites, like ESPN and Fox, and even local sites, like Valley News Live. No spammy clickbait sites that are difficult to navigate (example). No fake impressions.

The Hard Truth About In-House Marketing

When I worked in-house, I didn’t know this. It’s easy to get defensive about your budget and strategy, especially when you’re stretched thin across a hundred internal projects.

I used to roll my eyes when sales reps pitched me new advertising strategies. Another platform, another promise, another budget ask. But looking back? I wish I had asked more questions.

The advertising landscape is constantly evolving. If you’re relying on social media alone, you’re leaving a massive opportunity on the table.

Want to see the difference between Meta targeting and Trade Desk Programmatic targeting? Let me show you.

The first screenshot? That’s Facebook’s ‘purchase intent’ targeting—pretty limited. The second? That’s just a FRACTION of what’s available in The Trade Desk. With programmatic advertising, we’re not guessing based on broad interests—we’re getting in front of people actively looking to buy, using real purchase data and browsing behavior.

Social media has its place for being social—but it’s not the best tool for precision targeting.

Programmatic advertising through The TradeDesk reaches people where they actually spend their time—not just on Facebook. The best targeting data isn’t free—but it’s worth it.

Not sure if your advertising strategy is actually working? Let’s talk. →

Grace's Place | Passion Project